Artificial intelligence is changing marketing. We all know this now. But what I'm really curious about is not how much artificial intelligence will speed up marketers' work, but What kind of a marketing world will this speed create?
Will we produce more content? Will we run more ads? Will we try to reach more people?
Or are we entering a period where brands are more similar to each other amid all these technological developments?
Jessica Apotheker's TED talk recently “What Will Happen to Marketing in the Age of AI?” While thinking about it, I re-questioned a change that I have observed in the digital marketing industry for a long time.
While artificial intelligence makes content creation easier, does it also make it easier to do really good marketing?
I think the answer to these two questions is not the same.
Technology Saves Us Time, So How Do We Use That Time?
I have been working in the digital marketing field for over 15 years. I have witnessed many transformations, from the times when Google ads were just becoming widespread in Türkiye to today's artificial intelligence-supported search systems.
Every time a new technology comes into our lives, we encounter a similar promise: Our work will become easier, we will work faster and be more productive.
However, what happened most of the time was different.
As our work became easier, our expectations grew.
Jessica Apotheker gives a very good example in her speech. When word processors and spreadsheets became widespread, it was thought that people would work less. But over time, six-slide presentations turned into fifty slides. The number of data, reports and documents produced increased.
A similar situation is happening today with artificial intelligence.
Previously, creating a brand's monthly content plan, designing its visuals and preparing its texts required serious work.
Today, thanks to productive artificial intelligence, we can complete important parts of the same processes in a much shorter time.
But there is a critical question here:
If a brand produces 60 pieces of content per month instead of 12, does that really mean it's marketing five times better?
In my opinion, no.
Because marketing is not just about producing. It is about delivering the right message to the right person, at the right time and in a brand-specific way.
The Biggest Risk of Artificial Intelligence: Every Brand Is Similar to Each Other
When I look at social media content, advertising texts and corporate websites lately, there is something that catches my attention.
Many brands in different sectors speak almost the same sentences.
Similar headlines, similar images, similar advertising promises and repetitive content...
Moreover, artificial intelligence has the potential to further increase this similarity.
Because generative artificial intelligence largely learns from patterns in previously produced content. When we constantly ask for content from these systems with similar questions, we can naturally encounter similar results.
758 BCG consultants were examined in the experiment conducted by BCG with the contribution of Harvard Business School, MIT Sloan, Wharton and Warwick academics. The diversity of ideas in the creative product development task of the GPT-4 group was 41% lower than in the non-AI group. Participants' individual performance increased in the same task. This finding is limited to a specific sample and task; It should not be directly generalized to all marketing efforts. Scope of the research BCG's worksheet you can review.
It would not be correct to generalize this finding to all marketing studies. However, the risk it poses is quite significant.
If everyone uses the same tools, with similar commands and with similar goals, where will the difference between brands come from?
I think this will be one of the main problems of marketing in the coming years.
It will no longer be enough for a brand to just produce quality content.
It will need its own unique thought, narrative and perspective.
Abundance of Content Creates a Shortage of Attention
Today, when a consumer picks up his phone in the morning, he encounters messages from dozens of brands.
Reels on Instagram, Shorts on YouTube, sponsored results on Google, personalized offers on websites...
All brands want to be visible.
As the cost and time of content production decreases thanks to artificial intelligence, this competition can be expected to become more intense.
However, there is something we are missing here.
Our capacity to produce content is increasing, but people's attention span is not increasing at the same rate.
In fact, consumers can move away from repetitive messages more easily.
Therefore, one of the most important competitive advantages of brands in the coming period will not be to produce more content, but to develop content that people will actually want to be interested in.
For example, let's think of a hotel.
With artificial intelligence, it can share sea, pool, breakfast and room photos every day.
However, if all of these turn into similar content, where is the real story of the hotel?
The culture of the region where that hotel is located, the morning atmosphere, the stories of its employees, and the unique experiences that guests can have can create a much stronger communication area.
The same applies to the healthcare industry.
It is possible to fill a doctor's social media account with general health information prepared only with artificial intelligence.
But it is much more meaningful to reveal the doctor's expertise, his approach, the real questions that patients frequently ask, and how he makes complex issues understandable.
This is where human experience comes into play.
Artificial Intelligence Should Not Think Instead of Marketers
I do not see artificial intelligence as a technology that stands against the marketing industry.
On the contrary, I think it is a very important helper when used correctly.
Today, using artificial intelligence in content research, SEO analysis, advertising scenarios, data evaluation and production processes can provide serious advantages.
But there is a distinction in my approach:
Artificial intelligence can speed up the process. But deciding what the brand should say is still a strategic responsibility.
Understanding a brand's target audience, seeing the real needs of the consumer, noticing the gap in the market and developing a different idea is not just a matter of producing content.
This requires experience and judgment.
This distinction is even more evident, especially in sectors where I have worked for years, such as health and tourism.
The basis of correct communication in the healthcare industry is trust, expertise and ethical responsibility.
In tourism, it is necessary to understand experience, emotions, destination knowledge and people's travel motivations.
An artificial intelligence system can write hundreds of texts about Cappadocia.
However, the perspective of a marketer who has worked in Cappadocia, observed the tourism dynamics of the region and experienced the decision processes of visitors has a different value.
For this reason, I believe that technology should enhance the impact of human experience rather than replace it.
The Future of Marketing: Data Intelligence and Human Creativity
One of the important distinctions in Jessica Apotheker's talk is that marketing should focus on two different areas of talent.
On the one hand, there are artificial intelligence systems that analyze data, develop predictions and strengthen decision processes.
On the other hand, there is human creativity that produces original ideas, goes beyond the ordinary and gives character to brands.
I think successful marketing teams of the future will not see these two areas as competitors.
On the contrary, they will use it together.
Data-driven artificial intelligence: More accurate decisions
We have been talking about the importance of data in digital marketing for years.
Google Analytics, Search Console, advertising panels, conversion measurements and user behavior analysis...
It's no longer just a matter of reading this data.
To be able to create meaningful inferences for the future from data.
For example, by evaluating historical booking data, demand trends, seasonal search behavior and campaign performance together, a tourism brand can develop stronger predictions about which market it should focus on and when.
An e-commerce brand can make its communication strategy more efficient by examining customers' repurchase tendencies.
Of course, this requires the right data infrastructure, appropriate models, data quality and compliance with privacy rules.
In my opinion, the real power of artificial intelligence is not just in writing text, but in helping us make better decisions.
Human creativity: The power that differentiates a brand
On the other hand, we need to go beyond content that algorithms can easily standardize.
Creating a real brand story, developing a different campaign idea or recognizing a need that the consumer has not yet clearly expressed...
These constitute the creative side of marketing.
For me, creativity is not just about designing a beautiful visual or coming up with an eye-catching slogan.
Sometimes it's about asking a different question in an industry where everyone says the same thing.
Sometimes it means realizing that the brand needs to listen more than it talks.
Artificial intelligence can be used in these processes to develop ideas, evaluate alternatives and create rapid prototypes.
But when we leave all creative decisions to the brand, we may run the risk of losing its unique way of thinking.
We Will Encounter the Same Problem in SEO and Artificial Intelligence Searches
I see one of the important effects of this transformation on the SEO side.
For many years, brands have created content to become more visible on Google.
Today, AI-powered search experiences and GEO, or productive engine optimization, have been added to this.
Now brands want to be visible not only in classical search results, but also in the answers generated by artificial intelligence systems.
However, an important contradiction emerges here.
What kind of information ecosystem will emerge if everyone prepares content similar to artificial intelligence in order to be visible in artificial intelligence?
My opinion is that the importance of original experiences and reliable information sources will increase in the future.
A doctor's real knowledge in his field of expertise, a hotel's unique guide to its destination, or a brand's research on its industry can provide stronger differentiation than content that repeats general statements.
This does not mean that you will automatically rank higher in search engines.
However, it is important both to create value for the reader and to clearly demonstrate the brand's expertise.
In the SEO strategy of the future, it should be questioned not only how much content we produce, but also what new information and perspective we bring to the internet.
It Could Be a Big Opportunity for Small Brands
I don't think artificial intelligence transformation concerns only large companies.
I even believe that small brands can find important opportunities in this period.
Because some jobs that required large marketing teams and high production budgets in the past have become more accessible today.
A small hotel, boutique restaurant, local tourism business, or a doctor working in his own practice can conduct more structured digital communication with the right tools.
But small brands don't need to imitate the content production volume of big companies to compete with them.
On the contrary, they can benefit from the advantages of their own scale.
Getting to know their customers better, having a direct understanding of the service they offer, and being able to tell their own stories more sincerely can create an important area of differentiation.
At this point, I think the boutique working model is also valuable.
Because not every brand needs hundreds of automatic content.
Sometimes a properly prepared website, a few original videos, a strong SEO infrastructure and an advertising strategy that truly understands its target audience can be much more meaningful.
How Will the Role of Digital Marketing Agencies Change?
I think this transformation requires not only brands but also digital marketing agencies to question themselves.
To date, many agencies have described the services they offer with the amount of work they produce.
Number of monthly shares, number of images prepared, number of blogs written, number of campaigns managed...
However, thanks to artificial intelligence, some of these production processes are becoming increasingly easier.
Therefore, it may be difficult to differentiate service models based solely on production volume.
I think that the factor that will determine the value of agencies in the coming period will be how well they can give the right strategic direction to the brand, rather than producing more content.
The approach I adopted when establishing Social Zeplin Creative actually coincides with this idea.
I do not see web design, SEO, digital advertising, social media and content production as independent works.
These are all part of the same brand strategy.
It is important for a brand to be visible on Google. However, if the visitor cannot find the information he is looking for when he comes to the website, the value of that visibility decreases.
An impressive video can be prepared on social media. However, if the video does not reflect the true identity of the brand, it becomes difficult to establish a long-term connection.
Artificial intelligence can speed up many of these processes.
But putting the pieces together and creating the right strategy is still marketing's primary responsibility.
So How Should Marketers Improve Themselves?
The call Apotheker made at the end of his speech is quite clear: Identify your area of strength and improve your skills in that area.
If you are strong in data and analytical thinking, focus on the prediction and analysis capabilities of artificial intelligence.
If you have a strong creative side, improve your ability to generate original ideas.
I want to add one more point to this.
No matter what field you work in, do not lose your own thinking skills while learning to use technology.
Because in the coming period, the difference between marketers will not only be determined by who uses better artificial intelligence tools.
It will also be decisive who asks the right questions, interprets the data better, understands the brand better and develops more original ideas.
Conclusion: The Future Needs More Meaning, Not More Content
I believe that artificial intelligence will radically change marketing.
However, the direction of this change will not only be determined by technology. How we use technology will also determine it.
Today, thanks to artificial intelligence, we can create dozens of content, hundreds of headlines and different advertising scenarios in a day.
But at the end of all this production, we still have to ask the same question:
Have we been able to come up with a truly different and valuable idea?
For me, the future of marketing lies in the answer to this question.
We can use artificial intelligence to produce more content. Or we can devote the time it gives us to better understand our customers, develop new ideas and create stronger strategies for brands.
I find the second way more valuable.
Because technology may change, the platforms used may change, algorithms may change.
But the basis of good marketing is still understanding people.
Artificial intelligence will speed up production. The difference will be made by those who know what we produce and why.
---
Resources
Note: Research findings should be evaluated in the context of a specific group of participants and task.
Where should your brand start?
Share your website and priority. Let us define the scope together.
